
So frustrating. This photo sums it up pretty well actually. That’s Andrew Maxwell getting sacked on the last offensive play as the Spartans attempted a lame scramble that came up way short just after he had way overthrown three passes in a row. Why was Maxwell even playing? What was going on with the play calling? Where was the offense from a week ago? Why not run the ball more, and why always up the middle?
Notre Dame is good, but very beatable. Even with the 100+ yards given away from penalties (some deserved, some questionable), MSU could have and should have beaten them.

On defense, Michigan State was solid. ND struggled against the Spartan defense to the tune of 220 total yards of offense; 142 yards in the air and 78 yards on the ground. The Irish only converted six of 17 third downs and no fourth downs. And let’s not forget about the blocked punt on ND’s first possession, that was awesome (although it resulted in nothing).
That is the good news.
The bad news is that we gave up 115 yards in penalties including four pass interference calls and an defensive holding all of which resulted in yards plus a first down extending sputtering drives. I bet four of those six third down conversions go away if you take away the PI calls.
I speculated that Irish turn-overs would be a key factor to a Spartan victory. We had none. Actually, we had a fumble recovery and an interception, but both were taken away. I’m not saying the calls were bad, because they were legit actually. It’s more of a long, low, horrible moaning sound of a Spartan fan thinking this is 2012 all over again.

And then there was the offense. Notre Dame has a very good defense, so let’s not get to bent out of shape. The Irish applied a ton of pressure all day long and their coverage was excellent. Our numbers ended up being pretty even with Notre Dame’s with 254 yards of offense; 135 passing and 119 rushing. It did take Connor Cook too long to get in a groove. He came out looking nervous and his first five passes or so were off the mark. He did settle down but never really looked comfortable and in command.
And we had a few drops. I hate drops. it wasn’t a mega-drop meltdown like most 2012 games, but drops are drops and we’ve got to stop. MacGarrett Kings Jr. is really starting to look good with five receptions for 37 yards and a TD, I have big hopes for this guy making a big difference this year. Bennie Fowler hauled in three for 39 yards and Aaron Burbridge grabbed four for 20.
In total, seven Spartans had 16 receptions for 135 yards. These are okay numbers, but there is a total absence of big plays. The longest reception was 19 yards. The Spartans did not have a single 20-yard or longer play the entire game which makes for a very long field and a very long day.
The play calling seemed to fluctuate from okay to pretty predictable. Jeremy Langford was finding success pounding the ball, but he was rarely used on third down. MSU also seems to be paying homage to George Perles with the majority of our run plays being right up the middle.
The trick play with R. J. Shelton going deep to Fowler could have been a highlight-worthy play, but Fowler was completely covered and Shelton threw it anyway resulting in an Irish pick. I’m not going to bust the coaches for that play call, it was gutsy and came at a good time, but Shelton has to have a fallback plan for when the receiver is covered because that throw was doomed.
I did not like the decision to put Maxwell in for what ended up being a very short last drive. Maxwell is a good kid and I want for him to be a great QB; the next Kirk Cousins. But he just isn’t great and he’s not going to be. He must stay on the bench unless all other options are exhausted. Pulling Connor Cook isn’t going to help his confidence. It looked like he got dinged up so maybe he was benched for that, I don’t know. If Cook is our guy, then let’s commit to him and let him do what he does. He’ll either make the big play and build confidence or he’ll screw up and learn from his mistakes. Playing Maxwell is simply futile, 2012 taught us that.
The Spartans have next week off which is perfect timing. MSU needs to regroup, heal and get fired up for the B1G starting with an away game at Iowa. Make no mistake, Iowa is a threat. They are 3-1 and just beat Western Michigan much more convincingly than Michigan State did. The Hawkeyes have the Golden Gophers next week on the road and then the Spartans at home so maybe they will be a bit tired and beat up. I’ll take any advantage we can get.
Go GREEN!!!
